Dr. Bell spoke yesterday (Feb 1 2012) before the Kelowna Joint Review Panel
hearings on Enbridge’s proposed Northern Gateway pipeline, outlining
“four diseased elements” that put the pipeline proposal in a social and
political context and he condemned as dangerous Prime Minister Stephen
Harper’s concentration of power and the apparent depth of his associations with corporate interests.
When Bell finished speaking, he was surrounded by reporters. Here’s what he said:
I
am a family physician, in clinical practice for just over 36 years in
rural BC. As a professional reflex, I have a sensitivity towards the
behaviour of others, and towards the impact of my own conduct.
While
still in medical school, I learned that many of the most important
influences on a person’s health derive not just from what doctors do, or
even from the choices made by patients themselves, but from broad
trends in the community – from the immediate neighbourhood right up to
the planetary environment.
When I began my practice, however, the
term “ecosystem” was unknown, and the term “environment” referred almost
exclusively to a person’s immediate social or physical situation.
Today,
thanks to global telecommunications and transportation, and especially
the Internet and social media, our worldview has expanded greatly. As we
humans have multiplied exponentially, we have learned that we can
degrade the functional capacity of our planetary home, which in turn
affects our survival.
In 1995, I helped to found the
Canadian Association of Physicians for the Environment or CAPE.
Our purpose was to scientifically examine the intimate
inter-relationship between human and ecosystem health, and improve the
former by addressing the latter. With 5,500 members, CAPE has become the
environmental voice of the medical profession.
Today, however, I
am here not as representative of CAPE or any other organization. I am
speaking as just one person, and as a physician.
I want to address
what one might call “structural pathology” in the governance system in
Canada, which has led to the contention surrounding the
Enbridge Northern Gateway pipeline project – which I have followed closely since its inception.
Your
work as members of the Joint Review Panel is taking place in a social
context. As a medical professional – with, I might add, extra training
in psychotherapy – I would like to examine four diseased elements in
this social context, and suggest remedies for them.
The first pathological element is historical.
Up
until about 400 years ago, the land base subsumed within Canada was
home to various peoples, originally from Asian roots, broadly connected
by culture and race. They lived, like all our forebearers once did,
seeking survival in an unforgiving but also bountiful natural world.
Through a combination of force of arms, disease, mass immigration and
various legalistic arrangements – including a genocidal strategy called
the residential school system – the land base occupied by the original
inhabitants of this country was progressively reduced, and their role in
society was relentlessly marginalized. The small land base and the few
prerogatives left to them thus have become critically important to their
well being.
In Salmon Arm, I have patients, neighbours and
friends who are aboriginal, who embody the experiences I’ve just
referred to, both in their physiology and in their psyches. Many First
Nations communities, with similar individual and collective experiences,
are in the path of the proposed pipeline.
The second element in this structural pathology is the electoral system.
Elections to the House of Commons are based on the “first past the post” system. The elected candidate just has to get one vote
more than any other candidate – even if only a
minority of citizens actually vote in the first place.
This
kind of selection procedure, in a community with many disparate parts,
is psychologically grossly inefficient. Especially in complex or
conflictual situations, it generates a mixture of cynicism, despair and
anger.
The third element in this structural pathology is the nature of the Prime Minister’s Office, or PMO.
In
Britain, the PMO is surrounded by powerful committees and advisory
bodies whose comments and decisions have a major influence on government
decision-making and cannot be readily ignored.
In Canada, the PMO
has vastly more political power. It has, in fact, absolute veto power
over several hundred different government bodies.
Political power
in the Canadian system is profoundly more centralized than it is in
Britain, and far more than it is in the United States, with its system
of “checks and balances”.
Frankly, if Stephen Harper doesn’t like your report, he can, and by every indication he will, shelve it.
This
concentration of power in one element of Canada’s political structure,
for whatever murky historical reason, is an invitation to social
disaster. The illusion of “efficiency” in political decision-making is
subverted by the opportunity for hard-line autocracy.
In the 21
st century,
when my patients are being encouraged to take increasing responsibility
for their lives, such a concentration of power is anachronistic and
backward.
The final element in Canada’s structural
pathology is the expansion of the influence of the “corporation”, a business model that
uncouples personal responsibility from profit, and places dollar gains above all others.
It
is significant that as I sit talking to you here the Enbridge
consortium is applying to expand its Kitimat terminal from 11 to 16 oil
tanks. What clearer demonstration of absolute confidence in an eventual
approval could there possibly be?
Taken together:
- the relentless marginalization of First Nations, with their intimate connection to the ecosystem;
- the electoral system, which readily generates non-representative governments;
- the huge concentration of political power in the Prime Minister’s office; and
- the rise of corporate influence.
These elements create the pathological state that leads directly to us being here today.
The
planet is overcrowded, heating up, and steadily depleted of its natural
capital. But now we have a Prime Minister who is forcefully using the
overwhelming dominance afforded his office, to try and reshape this
country to his dated views.
Stephen Harper, according to recorded
evidence, has longed to be able to exercise such intense power, and
identifies with doing so now (several years ago he formally changed the
phrase “federal government” to “the government of Stephen Harper”).
His
own religious background suggests reasons for his overall orientation,
but his willingness to mask his own renowned intensity behind a rigidly
bland “persona” is a truer indication of his deep commitment to power.
This
approach to governance, exercised by a Prime Minister and government
elected by a minority of Canadians, has deepened the already strong
alliance between the corporate sector and the government. The former,
fixated on immediate- and short-term financial profitability, is drawn
to the latter, intent on maintaining its ascendancy, and vice versa.
The
result, in a situation like the one we are addressing today, is growing
social pathology. Frustration, anger, cynicism, depression and distrust
of leadership are on the ascendancy, as noted in the
Edelman Trust Barometer, released just before the World Economic Forum in Davos.
A
patient of mine in his mid-twenties came to my office recently to say
that he was deeply depressed and anxious, not about his love life, or
his financial situation, but about the overheated, depleted future he
was heading towards. He felt that the government in this country was
acting now to make it worse for him and his young children later.
So what is the cure for this disease?
It is four-fold, in my opinion.
- First,
we must, as a nation, work out a respectful, mutually satisfactory
relationship with Canada’s First Peoples – not destroy their culture by
stealth.
- Second, we must reform the electoral system to make it radically more representative.
- Third,
we must alter the power balance in the federal governance system so
that one person cannot pre-empt democratic processes as Stephen Harper
is now doing.
- And fourth, we must rein in the overwhelming power and influence of the corporate sector.
Until
we do these four things, our country is vulnerable to political, social
and ecological upheaval that will retard our development as a nation,
and likely offer ruin to the lives of future generations.
And it’s
going to make my personal and professional life more difficult, as I
minister to the anxiety and physical suffering of particularly the young
people in my community.
I therefore personally pledge my energies
and experience – here, today – to bringing about these changes, by
whatever means possible.
I hope you will too.
And I also
hope you will reject this flawed and destructive project, the inevitable
result of such a flawed and destructive – and pathological – process.
As posted at
http://elizabethmaymp.ca/news/blogs/2013/02/02/dr-warren-bell-on-the-northern-gateway-pipeline/